No need to fret if your furry friend is a picky eater—it’s a common occurrence, especially when selecting the right dog food for picky eaters. While some pups eagerly devour anything in sight (even non-food items), others have more discerning palates.
Dealing with a picky eater can pose challenges, but fear not; there are strategies to discover the perfect meal for your pup. While there’s no universal “best” food for choosy canines, you may find one that your furry companion prefers.
If not, fret not; there’s an array of methods to encourage your picky pup to consume their entire meal. Here are a few suggestions to try.
What Kinds of Dog Food are ideal for Picky Eaters?
Because dogs boast a heightened sense of smell, specific food varieties can entice even the most discerning palates.
For instance…
Wet dog foods emit natural aromas and offer a more gratifying flavor than heavily processed dry kibbles. This resemblance to real food enhances both the appearance and taste.
Why Are Wet Foods More Appealing To Dogs?
In contrast to mass-produced dry kibble pellets… Wet foods undergo cooking at significantly lower temperatures. Consequently, they sidestep the detrimental effects inflicted upon delicate vitamins and nutrients during processing. This preservation of natural flavor is also more probable.
Additionally, while dry kibble typically contains only 10% water… Wet dog foods boast a natural moisture content of approximately 75%—reminiscent of the wholesome human food stocked in your home refrigerator.
This higher moisture level renders them more enticing to selective eaters. This characteristic also explains the abundance of wet recipes on our list below.
How To Choose The Dog Food for Picky Eaters?
- High-Quality Proteins: Prioritize real meat as the main ingredient. Chicken, turkey, beef, lamb, and fish offer excellent protein sources. Avoid ambiguous labels like “meat meal” or “by-products” for optimal nutrition. Opt for alternate protein sources if your dog has meat allergies, such as egg-based or plant-based foods.
- Wholesome Carbohydrates: Look for whole grains like brown rice, oats, barley, or sweet potatoes for energy and nutrients. Avoid fillers like corn or wheat.
- Essential Fatty Acids: Ensure the food contains omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, which are vital for skin, coat, and overall health. Sources like fish oil or flaxseed are beneficial.
- No Artificial Additives: Choose foods free from artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives. Natural options are best.
- Avoid Harmful Fillers: Steer clear of excessive fillers like soy, corn, or artificial additives, which offer little nutritional value and can be challenging to digest.
Best Dog Food for Picky Eaters
The Farmer’s Dog
The Farmer’s Dog
The Farmer’s Dog subjects its recipes to stringent nutritional adequacy testing through live feeding trials spanning over 6 years, involving dogs of various breeds, sizes, and ages.
Pros
Human-grade, vet-designed food
Highly palatable for picky eaters
Nutritionally balanced and carefully formulated
Cons
Relatively high cost compared to traditional dog food options
Limited availability in certain regions
- Main ingredients: USDA beef, sweet potato, lentils, carrot, USDA beef liver
- Type: Grain-free (sweet potato, lentils, carrot)
- Design For: All Life Stages
- Ideal for: Adults and puppies (including large breeds)
The Farmer’s Dog Beef Recipe stands out among fresh formulations, featuring USDA beef as its primary ingredient alongside sweet potato, lentils, and carrot. With 39% protein, 29% fat, and 24% estimated carbs, it boasts a balanced nutritional profile and a fat-to-protein ratio of about 73%.
Crafted by a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, this human-grade dog food undergoes rigorous live-feeding trials over six years, ensuring nutritional adequacy and palatability. Praised by satisfied customers, it’s a top choice for picky eaters.
One enthusiastic buyer exclaimed, “Pubby is SOOO picky, and his stomach is a little sensitive. We made the switch to a fresh-food diet.
The Farmer’s Dog Beef Recipe is a standout option, combining premium ingredients, nutritional expertise, and unbeatable palatability to satisfy tail-wagging and pet parents.
Just Food For Dogs
Just Food For Dogs
JustFoodForDogs Pantry Fresh recipes undergo rigorous testing and are recommended by veterinarians for their freshness and quality.
Pros
High-quality, human-grade ingredients
Provides essential amino acids for dog health
Long shelf life (up to two years)
Cons
Relatively high carbohydrate content
Limited variety compared to some other brands
- Main ingredients: Beef, beef hearts, potatoes, carrots, sweet potatoes
- Type: Fresh
- Profile: Maintenance
- Ideal for: Adults only
Among the diverse array of fresh recipes from Just Food for Dogs, Beef and Russet Potato shine as a delectable option. With beef and beef hearts leading the ingredient list, complemented by potatoes, carrots, and sweet potatoes, this recipe offers a wholesome meal tailored for adult dogs.
Boasting a dry matter label analysis of 28% protein, 28% fat, and 36% estimated carbs, it achieves a balanced nutritional profile with a fat-to-protein ratio of about 100%.
Crafted with veterinarian guidance, JustFoodForDogs Pantry Fresh Beef and Russet Potato ensures quality and freshness. These meals, suitable for adult dogs only, can be safely stored for up to two years without refrigeration until opened. One buyer raved, “My dog relishes whichever fresh food recipe she gets. Not a picky eater.”
In summary, Just Food For Dogs Beef and Russet Potato offers a fresh and nutritious option for adult canine companions, backed by vet recommendations and glowing customer reviews.
Nom Nom Fresh
Nom Nom Fresh
Nom Nom recipes are crafted with fresh, human-grade ingredients and designed to meet dogs’ nutritional needs at every stage of life.
Pros
Enriched with manganese gluconate and chelated minerals
Grain-free recipe suitable for dogs with dietary sensitivities
Ideal for all life stages, including puppies and large breeds
Cons
Relatively high carbohydrate content
It may not be suitable for dogs with specific ingredient allergies
- Main ingredients: Ground beef, russet potatoes, eggs, carrots, peas
- Type: Grain-free (eggs, carrots, peas)
- Design For: All Life Stages
- Ideal for: Adults and puppies (including large breeds)
Delving into the nutritional breakdown, the recipe boasts a commendable 35% protein, 17% fat, and 40% estimated carbs, resulting in a fat-to-protein ratio of approximately 50%. The inclusion of manganese gluconate and three other chelated minerals is noteworthy, elevating its nutritional value beyond typical pet foods.
Offering affordability without compromising quality, Nom Nom Beef Mash stands out as a moist and flavorful option, perfect for even the fussiest eaters.
Its exceptional palatability makes it highly recommended among satisfied customers, with one reviewer noting, “Mya has suffered from colitis & IBS for many years, and she’s also the pickiest with food. Since being on Nom Nom, she is eating much better & has perfect poop!!!”
In summary, Nom Nom Fresh Beef Mash represents the epitome of canine culinary excellence, delivering nutrition and flavor in every bite, making it a paw-sitively perfect choice for discerning pet parents.
Ollie Fresh Dog Food
Ollie Fresh Dog Food
Ollie’s fresh dog food provides a balanced and nutritious diet for dogs, crafted with quality ingredients to meet their dietary needs at every stage of life.
Pros
Veterinarian-designed meals tailored to age, weight, breed size, and activity level
Made with 100% human-grade ingredients
Suitable for all life stages, from puppies to large adult dogs
Cons
Relatively high carbohydrate content
It may not be ideal for dogs with specific grain allergies
- Main ingredients: Chicken, carrots, peas, rice, chicken liver
- Type: Grain-inclusive (rice)
- Design For: All Life Stages
- Ideal for: Adults and puppies (including large breeds)
Delving into the nutritional breakdown, the recipe boasts an impressive 36% protein, 18% fat, and 38% estimated carbs, resulting in a balanced fat-to-protein ratio of about 50%. Designed by veterinarians and crafted with 100% human-grade ingredients, this meal is tailored to meet your dog’s individual needs based on age, weight, breed size, and activity level.
With its exceptional freshness and nutritional quality, Ollie Fresh Dog Food stands out as a top-notch canine diet, recommended with confidence by satisfied customers. One reviewer shared, “I ordered Ollie’s fresh chicken food, and Mocha loves it!!! I like the cute mixing dish and scoop, too.”
In summary, Ollie Fresh Chicken with Carrots encapsulates the epitome of canine culinary excellence, providing nutrition and flavor to satisfy tails and pet parents.
Raised Right Fresh Human-Grade Dog Food
Raised Right Fresh Human-Grade Dog Food
Raised Right offers an array of fresh, human-grade dog food recipes, providing high-quality nutrition and variety for discerning canine palates.
Pros
High protein content with low fat-to-protein ratio
Wide recipe selection suitable for picky eaters
Made with human-grade ingredients
Cons
Limited availability
Higher price point
- Main ingredients: Beef, beef heart, carrots, beef liver, cranberries
- Type: Grain-free (carrots, cranberries)
- Design For: Maintenance
- Ideal for: Adult dogs only
Analyzing the nutritional composition, the recipe boasts an impressive 61% protein, 24% fat, and 8% estimated carbs, resulting in a favorable fat-to-protein ratio of about 39%. This high protein content and low fat-to-protein ratio affirm the food’s quality, offering canine companions a nutritious and satisfying meal.
Renowned as one of the best fresh, human-grade dog foods available, Raised Right impresses with its extensive recipe selection, catering to even the pickiest eaters. Highly recommended by satisfied customers, one reviewer shared, “My dog loves Raised Right and even eats the vegetables. She licks her bowl clean after every meal.”
In summary, Raised Right Fresh Beef epitomizes excellence in canine nutrition, providing a delectable and nutritious option that dogs love and pet parents trust.
Merrick Lil’ Plates Small Breed Recipe
Merrick Lil’ Plates Small Breed Recipe
Merrick Lil’ Plates offers a variety of wet recipes tailored for small breeds, providing essential nutrients and flavors suitable for discerning palates.
Pros
Balanced wet food with high omega-3 fatty acids
Includes glucosamine and chondroitin for joint health
Contains prebiotics and probiotics for digestion support
Cons
Limited availability
Some dogs may have sensitivities to certain ingredients.
- Main ingredients: Beef, beef broth, venison broth, beef liver, dried egg whites
- Type: Grain-free (dried egg whites, dried ground peas)
- Profile: Maintenance
- Ideal for: Adult dogs only
Analyzing the nutritional breakdown, the recipe boasts an impressive 44% protein, 17% fat, and 31% estimated carbs, resulting in a favorable fat-to-protein ratio of about 38%. Noteworthy is its fully balanced nature, featuring above-average omega-3 fatty acids, glucosamine, and chondroitin, promoting healthy skin, joints, and overall well-being.
Designed with prebiotics and probiotics to support digestion, Merrick Lil’ Plates Teeny Texas Steak Tips earns praise as a nutritious and palate-pleasing option for smaller, picky breeds.
Highly recommended by satisfied customers, one reviewer shared, “Our dogs are 15 years old. One has had several teeth pulled, so some foods are hard for her to eat. The other is just plain picky. They both love this!”
In summary, Merrick Lil’ Plates Small Breed Recipe Teeny Texas Steak Tips epitomizes excellence in small-breed nutrition, offering a delectable and nourishing option that delights even the most discerning canine companions.
Canidae All Life Stages Wet Formula
Canidae All Life Stages Wet Formula
Canidae All Life Stages Wet Formula provides a delicious and nutritious meal option for puppies and adult dogs, making it popular among pet owners seeking versatile wet food options.
Pros
Fully-balanced grain-inclusive wet food
Suitable for picky eaters and sensitive stomachs
Offers a variety of nutrients for all life stages
Cons
It may contain allergenic ingredients for some dogs
The texture may be too soft for dogs that prefer crunchier food
- Main ingredients: Chicken, chicken broth, chicken liver, dried egg product, brown rice
- Type: Grain-inclusive (brown rice, barley)
- Design For:: All Life Stages
- Ideal for: Adults and puppies (including large breed puppies)
Analyzing the nutritional composition, the recipe boasts an impressive 41% protein, 30% fat, and 22% estimated carbs, resulting in a favorable fat-to-protein ratio of about 72%. Renowned for its popularity and taste, this fully-balanced wet food is highly recommended for puppies and adult dogs, offering a nutritious and satisfying option.
Praised by satisfied customers, one reviewer shared, “My 12-pound terrier mix is very picky and also has a sensitive stomach. She enjoys this taste, which keeps her regular, so I give it 5 stars. Recommend.”
In summary, Canidae All Life Stages Chicken and Rice Formula exemplifies excellence in wet dog food, providing nutrition and flavor to delight even the most discerning canine companions.
Blue Buffalo Life Protection
Blue Buffalo Life Protection
Blue Buffalo Life Protection provides a budget-friendly yet nutritious option for adult dogs, making it popular among pet owners seeking quality dry food.
Pros
Optimal balance of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids
It contains chelated minerals for better absorption
Affordable and fully balanced option
Cons
It may contain grains, which some dogs may be sensitive
Carbohydrate content may be higher than desired for some dogs
- Main ingredients: Deboned chicken, chicken meal, brown rice, barley, oatmeal
- Type: Grain-inclusive (brown rice, barley, oatmeal)
- Profile: Maintenance
- Ideal for: Adult dogs only
Analyzing the nutritional composition, the recipe boasts 27% protein, 16% fat, and 50% estimated carbs, resulting in a fat-to-protein ratio of about 58%. Its optimal balance of omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids is noteworthy, promoting a shiny coat and healthy skin.
Additionally, including zinc amino acid chelate and three other organic minerals enhances its nutritional value, typically found only in premium pet foods.
Affordable yet fully balanced, Blue Buffalo Life Protection Adult Chicken and Brown Rice are ideal for picky eaters. Highly recommended by satisfied customers, one reviewer shared, “Our dog has used the puppy version of this food since he was a few months old. When we transitioned to it, he was instantly interested in/excited about the adult version. Very pleased!”
In summary, Blue Buffalo Life Protection Adult Chicken and Brown Rice epitomize excellence in dry dog food, offering both affordability and nutrition to keep tails wagging and pet parents satisfied.
Orijen Dog Food
Orijen Dog Food
Champion Petfoods’ commitment to quality and biologically appropriate diets makes Orijen a top choice for pet owners seeking premium dry food.
Pros
High protein content sourced from quality meats
The biologically appropriate diet advocated by Champion Petfoods
Fully balanced for optimal nutrition
Cons
It may contain allergenic ingredients for some dogs
Relatively high carbohydrate content compared to other options
- Main ingredients: Chicken, turkey, flounder, whole mackerel, chicken liver
- Type: Grain-free (eggs)
- Design For: All Life Stages
- Ideal for: Adults and puppies (including large breeds)
Analyzing the nutritional composition, the recipe boasts an impressive 43% protein, 20% fat, and 28% estimated carbs, resulting in a favorable fat-to-protein ratio of about 47%. Champion Petfoods, the esteemed maker of Orijen, advocates for a meat-based, biologically appropriate diet, making this high-protein recipe a superior option for discerning pet parents.
Highly recommended by satisfied customers, one reviewer shared, “My dog is a picky eater who has been very bored with her previous dry food. She eats this Orijen food as soon as I place the bowl down. The premium ingredients make me feel like I have made the correct food choice for my fur baby.”
In summary, Orijen Original epitomizes excellence in dry dog food, providing nutrition and flavor to keep tails wagging and pet parents satisfied.
Wellness Complete Health Dry Dog Food
Wellness Complete Health Dry Dog Food
Wellness Complete Health offers a balanced, grain-inclusive dry dog food option, ideal for pet parents seeking comprehensive nutrition for their furry companions.
Pros
Includes zinc proteinate and chelated minerals
Grain-inclusive
Balanced nutrition with joint supplements and stomach probiotics
Cons
Relatively high carbohydrate
It may contain allergenic ingredients for sensitive dogs
- Main ingredients: Deboned turkey, chicken meal, salmon meal, oatmeal, ground brown rice
- Type: Grain-inclusive (oatmeal, ground brown rice)
- Profile: Maintenance
- Ideal for: Adult dogs only
Analyzing the nutritional breakdown, the recipe boasts 31% protein, 17% fat, and 44% estimated carbs, resulting in a fat-to-protein ratio of about 54%. Noteworthy is the inclusion of zinc proteinate and three other chelated minerals, typically found only in premium pet foods, enhancing its nutritional value.
Ideal for pet parents who prefer dry kibbles, Wellness Complete Health Small Breed Turkey offers a fully balanced and grain-inclusive option.
Highly recommended by satisfied customers, one reviewer shared, “I have owned many dogs, and my 2 now are the first picky eaters I have ever had. After trying about half a dozen foods, they love this one. Their coats look great, and their weight is perfect. It also has joint supplements and stomach probiotics. Highly recommend.”
In summary, Wellness Complete Health Small Breed Turkey epitomizes excellence in dry dog food, providing quality nutrition and palatability to keep tails wagging and pet parents satisfied.
How to Make Mealtime Fun for a Picky Eater?
Your furry friend may not always leap for joy at their food bowl, and that’s alright. But there are ways to ignite their excitement for mealtime. Here are some tips.
- Introduce Dog Food Toppers: If dry dog food fails to captivate your pup, consider adding a kibble topper instead of switching to wet food. These toppers, in various forms like soups or broths, offer diverse flavors and health benefits, such as pumpkin for digestion or chicken bone broth for immunity.
- Switch Food Consistencies: Try transitioning between dry and wet food to entice your dog with different textures. Heating wet food can enhance its aroma, making it more appetizing.
- Experiment with Rotational Feeding: For pups craving variety, rotate between different food options, such as dry and wet, with varied main ingredients. Ensure gradual changes to avoid digestive issues.
- Wait Until Your Dog is Hungry: Designated mealtimes can stimulate your dog’s anticipation for food, encouraging them to eat promptly. If they don’t finish within 20 minutes, remove the food until the next feeding time.
- Increase Exercise: Boost your dog’s appetite by engaging them in vigorous activities like fetch or long walks. Physical exertion can revitalize their interest in eating.
- Avoid Table Scraps: Please resist the temptation to feed your dog from the table or with excessive treats, as this can dampen their appetite for regular meals.
- Consult Your Veterinarian: If your dog’s eating habits change suddenly, consult your vet to rule out any underlying health issues. They can provide guidance and address concerns promptly.
Some Posts You Wanna Read More
Frequently Asked Questions
Why Are Dogs Picky Eaters?
While humans eat almost anything, dogs can be picky for a few reasons:
- Super Smellers: Dogs have keen noses. If food doesn’t smell good, they may refuse it.
- Taste Preferences: Like us, dogs have favorites—some like meat and some veggies.
- Boredom: Eating the same thing gets dull. Mixing it up or adding toppings can help.
- Health or Dental Issues: Picky eating might signal health problems, so see a vet.
- Spoiling: If dogs get human food, they may prefer it over their own.
How to Switch The New Dog Food?
Dr. Gary Richter offers a straightforward feeding tip to minimize the risk of upsetting your dog’s stomach when transitioning to a new food: a gradual introduction is critical.
Begin by blending 20% of the “new” food with 80% of the “old” food. Then, for 8 to 9 days, gradually increase the proportion of the new food until it comprises 100% of their diet.
| Schedule | Old Food | New Food |
| Days 1 and 2 | 80% | 20% |
| Days 3 and 4 | 60% | 40% |
| Days 5 and 6 | 40% | 60% |
| Days 7 and 8 | 20% | 80% |
| Day 9 | 0% | 100% |
Following this gradual transition plan can help ensure a smooth and comfortable switch for your furry friend.
Which type of wet food works best as a topper?
Wet dog food typically comes in two textures: chunky and fine-chopped (pate). Most picky eaters gravitate towards wet food, so they might sift through the kibble to only eat the wet portion.
Therefore, opting for a wet recipe with a fine-chopped texture is advisable. This makes it more challenging for your dog to separate the wet food from the dry pellets.
When is the ideal time to transition your dog to senior dog food?
You should consider switching your dog to senior dog food based on their size and age. Small breed dogs are typically considered seniors around 7 years old, while larger breeds may reach senior status at 5 to 6 years old due to their shorter lifespans.
It’s important to monitor your dog’s health and consult with your veterinarian to determine if a senior formula is necessary. Specialized senior diets can benefit older dogs, particularly those needing joint support, digestive health maintenance, weight management, or dental care.
For recommendations, visit The Doggo Bio’s Top 10 Senior Dog Foods. Always ensure any dietary changes are made gradually and under veterinary guidance for your dog’s well-being.
Conclusion
Remember that our furry companions have unique preferences and personalities, especially when choosing dog food for picky eaters. Like us, they deserve nutritious and delightful meals catering to their taste buds and health needs.
So, here’s to celebrating the journey of dog food evolution and embracing our discerning eaters with open arms (and treat-filled hands). May your dog’s dining experience be filled with joy, tail wags, and slobbery kisses! Woof-tastic adventures await, my friends!
Kindly be advised that the information presented is intended solely for educational purposes and does not substitute professional guidance. We highly encourage seeking advice from a veterinarian or pet nutrition specialist for any queries concerning your dog’s dietary or health requirements.